լƵ

XClose

Department of Political Science

Home
Menu

US midterms: five reasons why the election results matter

11 January 2023

Thomas Gift and Julie Norman write in The Conversation

A pile of badges with the USA flag and the words 'midterm election' on them.

Written by Thomas Gift and Julie Norman, Centre on US Politics.
Published 9 January.


As the US midterm election results roll in, it’s evident that the Republican “red wave” that many experts anticipated hasn’t materialised. Early numbers indicate that Republicans are likely to take back thebut by slimmer numbers than expected, even as theremains a toss-up. While it might see more of a ripple than a wave, Washington still appears braced for divided government.

In the US Congress, Republicans will focus on maintaining a united front against Democrats and trying to ensure that President Joe Biden only serves one term. Policy and legislative gridlock is likely to be the watchword in Washington over the next two years.

Although Biden may have some power toif Democrats keep control of the Senate, other key White House priorities – including on the environment, healthcare and reproductive rights – will grind to a halt. Here’s five other key takeaways:

1. Spending cuts

If there’s one place where House Republicans, in particular, will leverage their newfound clout, it’s in the area of government spending. Federal expenditures, which haveunder the Biden administration, will likely be reigned in.

Republican leadership will try to force Democrats’ hands in reforming social security and Medicare in exchange for allowing anthe borrowing limit for the US Treasury that keeps the federal government operating.

The scope and scale of spending cuts will in large part be determined by. Reforming welfare is known as the “third rail of American politics” because of its potential to damage officials who deign to take away financial support from Americans. While fiscal hawks such as Republican congressman Jim Jordan of Ohio, co-founder of the Freedom Caucus, have expressed interest in, populists in the party may be more wary.

2. Launching investigations

Where Capitol Hill will most see action, however, is in aaimed at the executive branch – an itch that Republicans have been yearning to scratch since Biden took office. Partly payback for Trump’s two impeachments, and partly due to anger over the White House’s agenda, Republicans will exploit every opening to, including on,,, and the.

Some hardline Republican House members have eventhe idea of impeaching Biden, but that likelihood seems remote. Ultra Trump supporters like Marjorie Taylor Greene, a Republican congresswoman from Georgia, will continue to press for any action that creates a self-serving political spectacle.

Yet more mainstream Republicans realise that path is. The risk is being perceived as ignoring “kitchen-table issues” such as inflation while pursuing a partisan vendetta against Biden.

3. Attitudes to China and Ukraine

Internationally, the midterms are also likely to have limited impact in altering concrete policies. Many USthat if Republicans wrested control of even one congressional chamber, they’d tighten Washington’s purse strings and jeopardise America’s commitments abroad.

Most notably, speculations arose about pulling back support to Ukraine after House minority leader Kevin McCarthy declared last month that a Republican Congress would be disinclined to write a “” for the war effort.

A stark pivot away from Kyiv is unlikely, however, even amid a conflict with no foreseeable end. Despite awithin the Republican party, there’s broad-based support around Washington for backing Ukraine’s military defences. That’s in line with public opinion for countering Putin’s war, with roughlyagreeing that the US should continue to offer financial and military assistance to Kyiv.

Similarly, foreign policy toward China is an area where Republicans and Democrats remain united. Biden has backed off Trump’s dialed-up rhetoric toward Beijing, but has still defaulted to his predecessor’s position of waging.

4. Implications for US democracy

While the midterms matter on their own – and shouldn’t just be viewed as a warm-up for 2024 – there’s a reason why all eyes will now shift toward the next presidential election. Democrats framed the midterms not just as a vote on policies, but as a referendum on the.

¾ٳright-wing election deniers on the ballot, many worried that the groundwork could be set for an even more turbulent election in 2024 than the nation survived in 2020.

Early polling, however, indicates that Americans are pushing back against many extreme election deniers, especially at the state level. Voters inand Michigan rejected Trump-backed candidates for governor who would have held considerable sway over certifying electoral votes. What’s more, vocal election-denying candidates for– the official who certifies election results in most states – havein many races, underperforming other Republicans.

5. Trump’s future role

Meanwhile, Trump’s grip on the party may be increasingly challenged by rival Ron DeSantis, whoin the Florida governor’s race by a double-digit margin, flipping districts that used to be safely Democrat and taking large swaths of the Hispanic/Latino vote. Although results for Trump-backed candidates have been, it’s clear that Trump’s blessing wasn’t a surefire guarantee of victory, and that candidatecontinues to matter.

All of this doesn’t ensure there won’t be threats to election results, either in this cycle or 2024. The scourge of election denialism has become bigger than just Trump or his most ardent allies, morphing into a full-blownthat may prove hard to contain. Still, the apparent rejection of the most extreme candidates suggests that many Americans – from both parties – want stability back, especially in the core institution of free and fair elections.